Pizza restaurants

Pinons Pizza Company

4.6 106 reviews Closed 23 Birch Hill Rd, Locust Valley, NY 11560, United States

Discover this place

Piñons Pizza Company is a neighborhood pizza restaurant located at 23 Birch Hill Rd in Locust Valley, NY. The menu showcases a variety of pizza options with a focus on fresh, flavorful toppings such as pepperoni and peppers, hot mesa, and maple bacon. Alongside its signature pies like the Piñons Plain and Pepperoni and Pesto Pizza Margherita, the restaurant offers a selection of salads including the Pinons Salad and chopped kale salad. The atmosphere is casual and inviting, suitable for both families and small groups seeking a relaxed dining experience. Complementing the main dishes, guests can enjoy desserts like the Cowboy Cookie and Brownie with Ice Cream, as well as a curated list of beverages, including local Maine beer and specialty drinks like Arnold Palmer and sangria. Piñons Pizza Company emphasizes a balance between classic pizza flavors and inventive combinations, making it a notable spot for those in the Locust Valley area looking for straightforward, well-crafted pizza and accompanying fare.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Outdoor seating
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service
Live music

Popular for

Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

Casual

Crowd

Family-friendly

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Pinons Pizza Company before visiting.

Reviews for Pinons Pizza Company

4.6

106 reviews

100%

12%

Review highlights

Based on 106 reviews

Piñons Pizza Company is widely praised for its inviting atmosphere and consistently high-quality food. Reviewers frequently highlight the restaurant’s unique menu offerings, including organic ingredients and inventive toppings, which set it apart from typical pizza places. The brick oven thin crust pizzas receive particular acclaim, as do complementary dishes like chicken wings, salads, and desserts. The welcoming ambiance and friendly, attentive staff contribute to a comfortable dining experience that appeals to both regulars and newcomers. Additionally, the full bar and thoughtfully curated beverage selection enhance the overall appeal, making it a popular spot for social gatherings. Patrons appreciate the warm, laid-back vibe that provides a refreshing alternative to other local dining options. Overall, Piñons Pizza Company is recognized for its combination of great food, excellent service, and a vibrant yet relaxed atmosphere.

Aggie S

Jul 28, 2025

Third time at Piñons and it keeps getting better. Sat with Lotus at the bar yesterday who is so lovely. My husband was concerned about space and feeling uncomfortable but it was PERFECT! A note to the owner: the pesto/vodka/pepperoni special is too good not to keep on regular menu. I saw a photo of it and that alone made me make my first reservation-finally got to try it last night and it was exceptional. The pepperoni and peppers pizza is also stellar. Bacon dates, meatballs, wings WOW! This is a truly special place. Will keep coming back because it’s such a treat and you don’t feel horrible when you leave. Really appreciate the high level of quality and care it takes to move such ingredients and keep providing that level of service. Thank you Piñons!

aaron grotas

Jun 26, 2025

Great vibes. Great food. Nice staff. I love pizza. This place does it right. Salad wings pizza drinks. Not much else. Good tunes a full bar. If you live near here check it out !!

Linda S

Jun 09, 2025

I love the pizza as well as their chicken wings warm olives and salads. The cookie dessert is also delicious. I love the ambiance makes me feel I’m away from the usual LI spots, very friendly as well.

Michael Risso

Apr 28, 2025

Brick oven thin crust pizza. Delicious dessert. Must try the bacon wrapped dates.

Michael Marolda IV

Apr 18, 2025

Best restaurant pizza you can get on LI. Organic ingredients and interesting toppings make for an eventful night. Awesome beer, wine, and liquor selection. Ask for the waiter who looks like Dolph Lundgren. You do not want to miss Piñons - one of the best spots to hangout, drink, enjoy some great company.

Ian Siegel

Apr 02, 2025

We have been coming here since they opened. It is our favorite pizza spot. Never a disappointment! Wonderful staff. Excellent food. Strong cocktails. Perfect in every way..